Agatha All Along

Kathryn Hahn

Agnes O'Connor / Agatha Harkness

Joe Locke

Teen

Sasheer Zamata

Jennifer Kale

Ali Ahn

Alice Wu-Gulliver

Debra Jo Rupp

Mrs. Hart

Patti LuPone

Lilia Calderu

Aubrey Plaza

Rio Vidal

Emma Caulfield

Sarah Proctor / "Dottie Jones"

Kate Forbes

Evanora Harkness

Asif Ali

Abilash Tandon / "Norm"

Okwui Okpokwasili

Salem Seven / Vertigo

David Payton

John Collins / "Herb"

Chau Naumova

Salem Seven / Coyote

Bethany Curry

Salem Seven / Crow

Athena Perample

Salem Seven / Fox

Alicia Vela-Bailey

Salem Seven / Owl

Britta Grant

Salem Seven / Rat

Marina Mazepa

Salem Seven / Snake

David Lengel

Jones

Chloe Camp

Young Lilia

Laura Boccaletti

Lilia's Maestra

Maria Dizzia

Rebecca Kaplan

Paul Adelstein

Jeff Kaplan

Amos Glick

Dennis the Mailman

Elaine Valdes

Customer #1

Paria Akbarshahi

Customer #2

Elizabeth Anweis

Lorna Wu

Scott Butler

The Doctor

Scott Butler

The Doctor

Jade Quon

The Demon

Miles Gutierrez-Riley

Eddie

Evan Peters

Ralph Bohner

James Bostick

EMT

Erica Frene

Event Planner

Alexandria Shuval-Weiner

Rabbi Levin

Abel Lysenko

Nicholas Scratch

Hannah Lowther

Forest Witch

Tetra Lloyd

Singing Forest Witch

Henriette Zoutomou

Village Witch

Holly Bonney

Tavern Witch

Kim Bass

Young Witch