Garfunkel and Oates

Riki Lindhome

Garfunkel

Kate Micucci

Oates

Mike Phirman

Lenny / Rule 34 Announcer / Sports Announcer

Natasha Leggero

Vivian

Michelle Zamora

Puppeteer

Sarah Burns

Cheryl

Busy Philipps

Karen

Rich Fulcher

Dr. Patel

Artemis Pebdani

Janice

Creed Bratton

Kazoo Man

Ben Kingsley

Ben Kingsley

Sugar Lyn Beard

Epiphany

Abby Elliott

Chevrolet

Jerry Lambert

Wesker-Wynn Boss

Karen Maruyama

Susie

Tig Notaro

Pumpernickel Place Producer

John Oates

Dirty D

Russ Walko

Puppeteer

Chris Parnell

Stan

Chris Hardwick

Himself

Steve Agee

Toy Store Cashier

Geoffrey Arend

Todd

Liz Cackowski

Yogurt Woman

Camille Chen

Caroline

Malcolm Barrett

Daniel

Kyle Dunnigan

Josh Duncan

Rob Huebel

Boomer (voice)

Anthony Jeselnik

Thomas

Lance Barber

Drew

Joel Michaely

Marcus

Ashley Johnson

Jane

Mo Mandel

Tom

Nick Thune

Nick

Christopher Smith

Darren

Brent Weinbach

Andy

Allison Buczkowski

Dancer

Ayesha Orange

Dancer

Tia Robinson

Dancer

Noureen DeWulf

Jennifer

Andy Kindler

Michael Andrew Carson

Edward Fordham, Jr.

Bouncer

Steve Little

Dennis

Toby Huss

Tom

Madeline Walter

Shelly

Kevin Pollak

Andrew

Kulap Vilaysack

Laura

Gerry Bednob

Pavel

Rose Abdoo

Magda

Ike Barinholtz

Director

Erin Cahill

Jenny

Eugene Cordero

Fred

Davey Johnson

Gator

Ann Maddox

Colleen

Kumail Nanjiani

Jordan

Jonah Ray

Charlie

Irene Choi

Bethany

Janina Gavankar

Dr. Sharma

Moshe Kasher

Receptionist

Dannah Feinglass Phirman

Meditation Voice

Vladimir Tevlovski

Stunt Coordinator

"Weird Al" Yankovic

Weird Al

Janie Haddad Tompkins

Venue Woman

Ari Graynor

Cornish Amberson

B.K. Cannon

Becky

Beth Dover

Fertility Nurse

Trevor Einhorn

Graham

Kathryn Burns

Dancer

Jillian Schmitz

Dancer

Becca Sweitzer

Dancer

Jimmy Bennett

Braden

Matthew Micucci

George

Joy Regullano

Cafe Waitress

Jason Ritter

Jason

Brandon Ruiter

Caden

T.J. Miller

Matthew

Issac Ryan Brown

Timmy