Um, Actually...

Mike Trapp

Self - Host

Michael Meir Saltzman

Self - Fact Checker

Ify Nwadiwe

Self - Host

Brian David Gilbert

Self - Fact Checker

Amy Vorpahl

Self - Contestant

Emma Fyffe

Self - Contestant

Becca Scott

Self - Contestant

Brennan Lee Mulligan

Self - Contestant

Siobhan Thompson

Self - Contestant

Erika Ishii

Self - Contestant

Jon Gutierrez

Self - Contestant

Haley Mancini

Self - Contestant

Shane Crown

Self - Contestant

Jordan Doll

Self - Contestant

Danielle Radford

Self - Contestant

Jessica Ross

Self - Contestant

Ally Beardsley

Self - Contestant

Amy Dallen

Self - Contestant

Joan Ford

Self - Contestant

Carolyn Page

Self - Contestant

Zac Oyama

Self - Contestant

Kirk Damato

Self - Contestant

Jessica Clemons

Self - Contestant

Jay Washington

Self - Contestant

Markeia McCarty

Self - Contestant

Kelly Nugent

Self - Contestant

Tao Yang

Self - Contestant

Matthew Mercer

Self - Contestant

Caldwell Tanner

Self - Contestant

Krystina Arielle

Self - Contestant

Rekha Shankar

Self - Contestant

Grant O'Brien

Self - Contestant / Self - Guest / Bartender

Michelle Nguyen Bradley

Self - Contestant

Dani Fernandez

Self - Contestant

Nick Marini

Self - Contestant

Winston A. Marshall

Self - Contestant

Andrew Rosas

Self - Contestant

Adam Conover

Self - Contestant

Isabella Roland

Self - Contestant

Luke Field

Self - Contestant

Liam Senior

Self - Contestant

Betsy Sodaro

Self - Contestant

Oscar Montoya

Self - Contestant

Eli Yudin

Self - Contestant

Jared Logan

Self - Contestant

Brian Murphy

Self - Contestant

Demi Adejuyigbe

Self - Contestant

Hector Navarro

Self - Contestant

Jon Gabrus

Self - Contestant

Ryan Anthony Martin

Self - Contestant

Malika Lim Eubank

Self - Contestant

Benjamin Siemon

Self - Contestant

Fiona Nova

Self - Contestant

Gustavo Sorola

Self - Contestant

Cody Ziglar

Self - Contestant

Persephone Valentine

Self - Contestant

Janie Stolar

Self - Contestant

Matt Acevedo

Self - Contestant

Karen Han

Self - Contestant

B. Dave Walters

Self - Contestant

Lily Du

Self - Contestant

Marisha Ray

Self - Contestant

Mike Drucker

Self - Contestant

Glenn Boozan

Self - Contestant

D.C. Pierson

Self - Contestant

Jackie Kashian

Self - Contestant

Dan Black

Self - Contestant

Zach Kornfeld

Self - Contestant

Jenny Lorenzo

Self - Contestant

Maggie Mae Fish

Self - Contestant

Sam Bashor

Self - Contestant

Kait Thompson

Self - Contestant

"Weird Al" Yankovic

Self - Guest

Ryan Creamer

Self - Contestant

Julia Prescott

Self - Contestant

Trisha Hershberger

Self - Contestant

Sam Maggs

Self - Contestant

Erik Voss

Self - Contestant

Aabria Iyengar

Self - Contestant

Damien C. Haas

Self - Contestant

Ivan Van Norman

Self - Contestant

Spencer Porter

Self - Contestant

Alice Wetterlund

Self - Contestant

Morgana Ignis

Self - Contestant

Coy Jandreau

Self - Contestant

Satine Phoenix

Self - Contestant

James Willems

Self - Contestant

Jonathan Braylock

Self - Contestant

Lindsay Katai

Self - Contestant

Liam O'Brien

Self - Contestant

Sam Riegel

Self - Contestant

Carlos Luna

Self - Contestant

Jasmine Bhullar

Self - Contestant

Johnny Stanton

Self - Contestant

Mano Agapion

Self - Contestant

Eme Ikwuakor

Self - Contestant

Rachel Bloom

Self - Contestant

Frank Garcia-Hejl

Self - Contestant

Alex Song-Xia

Self - Contestant

Alex Schmidt

Self - Contestant

Noah Diamond

Self - Contestant (as Noah Diamond-Stolzman)

David Gallegos

Self - Contestant

Shay Parsons

Self - Contestant

T.J. Gonzalez

Self - Contestant

Vanessa Guerrero

Self - Contestant

Chris Grace

Self - Contestant

Nikhil Clayton

Self - Contestant

Ross Bryant

Self - Contestant

Blaine Swen

Self - Contestant

Joey Bland

Self - Contestant

Daniel O'Brien

Self - Contestant

Thomas Middleditch

Self - Contestant

Emily Axford

Self - Contestant

Adam Lustick

Self - Contestant

Caldwell Tanner

Himself

Zach Sherwin

Self - Contestant

Emily Heller

Self - Contestant

Edgar Momplaisir

Self - Contestant

Haley Mancini

Herself

Natalie Palamides

Self - Contestant

Jonathan Coulton

Self - Guest

Saige Ryan

Self - Contestant

Omar Najam

Self - Contestant

Matt Kirshen

Self - Contestant

Mike Mearls

Self - Guest

Zeke Nicholson

Self - Contestant

Nathan Yaffe

Self - Contestant

Nick Mundy

Self - Contestant

Kristian Nairn

Self - Guest

Stef Woodburn

Self - Contestant

Chris Calilung

Self - Contestant

Alyssa Rouoneios

Self - Contestant

Jason Gong

Self - Contestant

Jeremy Puckett

Self - Contestant

Ryanni

Self - Contestant

Ken Napzok

Self - Contestant

Maddox

Self - Contestant

Lou Wilson

Self - Contestant

Nate Dern

Self - Contestant

Grae Drake

Self - Contestant

Raphael Chestang

Self - Contestant

Amy Dallen

Self - Contestant

Devon Deshaun Stewart

Self - Contestant

Kim Horcher

Self - Contestant

Becky Drysdale

Self - Contestant

SungWon Cho

Self - Contestant

Ben Joseph

Self - Contestant

Owen Parsons

Self - Contestant

Terence Wiggins

Self - Contestant

Vernon X. Odemns

Self - Contestant

Jeff Hiller

Self - Contestant

Lindsay Jones

Self - Contestant

David Kerns

Self - Contestant

Justin Matson

Self - Contestant

Clint McElroy

Self - Contestant

Travis McElroy

Self - Contestant

Justin McElroy

Self - Contestant

Marina Mastros

Self - Contestant

Maude Garrett

Self - Contestant

Morgan Lavandowska

Self - Contestant

Ian Adams

Self - Contestant

Steven Plescia

Self - Contestant

MT

Self - Contestant

Orion D. Black

Self - Contestant

Kendra Wells

Self - Contestant

Mark Rennie

Self - Contestant

Matthew 'Nando' Kelly

Self - Contestant

Brodie Reed

Self - Contestant

Taliesin Jaffe

Self - Contestant

Riley Silverman

Self - Contestant

Anthony Burch

Self - Contestant

Kara Klenk

Self - Contestant

Surena Marie

Self - Contestant

Michelle Khare

Self - Contestant

Jimmy Wong

Self - Contestant

Beth May

Self - Contestant

Freddie Wong

Self - Contestant

Frosk

Self - Contestant

Jujubee

Self - Contestant

Monét X Change

Self - Contestant

Trinity the Tuck

Self - Contestant

Austin Watson

Self - Contestant

Keith Habersberger

Self - Contestant

Elyse Willems

Self - Contestant

Dave McCormack

Self - Guest

Jordan Adika

Self - Contestant

Jarvis Johnson

Self - Contestant

Jonah Ray

Self - Contestant

Milana Vayntrub

Self - Contestant

Harvey Guillén

Self - Contestant

Azeem Jimoh

Self - Contestant

Amanda Lehan-Canto

Self - Contestant

Charlotte Avery

Self - Contestant

Rachel Bloom

Self - Contestant

Dante Basco

Self - Contestant

Janet Varney

Self - Contestant

Jack De Sena

Self - Contestant

Alan Tudyk

Self - Guest